Chloride requirements.JPG (18366 bytes)

Chloride requirements

Correcting potential damage from physiologic leaf spot is easy and inexpensive.  Leaf spotting in susceptible varieties occurs as whole plant Cl concentrations dropped below the 1000 to 1500 ppm threshold level (see leaf spot severity vs. plant Cl figure).  The approach to correcting potential damage is to ensure plant Cl does not fall below this concentration thru fertilization.   Generally, only 10-25 lbs/a of soil + fertilizer Cl is required to mnimized leaf spot damage in the absence of appreciable leaching.    The  relationship between leaf spot severity and soil (0-24" depth) plus fertilizer Cl for Redwin winter wheat (Figure 1, below) is typical of leaf spot susceptible varieties.   Leaf spot severity decreases exponentially as plant Cl concentrations approach the critical level, or until a minimum plateau level is reached.

PLS vs soil Cl.gif (6527 bytes)

Figure 1. Leaf spot severity (portion of flag leaf affected by chlorotic + necrotic lesions) vs. soil Cl relationships for Redwin winter wheat

 

Yield responses to chloride fertilization in winter wheat cultivars which exhibited leaf spot symptoms

Chloride fertilization has consistently increased winter wheat grain yield and mature kernel weights at sites with physiological leaf spot (Table 1). Yield responses to applied Cl averaged 6.9 bu/a or 10.0 %, but can vary considerably with location. Thousand kernel weight increases from applied Cl averaged 7.2%, hence kernel size is the most important yield component affected by Cl. Leaf spot suppression by Cl may explain a portion of the yield responses. A reduction in photosynthetic area due to lesion formation, particularly in the flag leaves, could affect yield by reducing kernel size at harvest.   Physiologic leaf spot is a problem of low Cl testing soils. The solution to correcting potential damage from physiologic leaf spot is to increase soil Cl, through fertilization, to levels above the threshold damage level. In the absence of soil testing (many soil testing labs currently do not perform soil Cl tests) it is recommended that growers apply 20-25 lbs/a Cl (40-50 lbs/acre 0-0-60 material) to fields where physiologic leaf spot has been a problem. Granular 0-0-60 is the most economic source of Cl to apply (.17/lb Cl), and the material application cost of this recommendation is only $3.40 to $4.25/acre. This material can be blended with nitrogen, and broadcast applied in the fall, or early spring to produce satisfactory results. While yield responses to Cl fertilizer at sites with physiologic leaf spot are variable, the cost of correcting physiologic leaf spot through 0-0-60 fertilization is small when contrasted with the potential for improved yields and economic return.

Table 1.  Chloride fertilization increased grain yield and mature kernel weights of leaf spot susceptible wheat varieties at field sites in Bighorn County,   Montana.

Location Year Soil Cl    Cultivar     Grain yield   Kernel wt. 
(0-24" depth) -Cl ¶ +Cl §  -Cl +Cl

lbs/a

------ bu/a ------

--g/1000 --

Garry Owen

1991

3.9

Redwin

47.0

49.5

28.6

31.7

Manning

49.5

51.6

31.5

34.0

Lodgegrass

1992

3.2

Redwin

56.9

62.8

33.5

36.6

Manning

69.8

76.4

35.7

38.8

Bighorn Mtn. foothills

1992

5.4

Redwin

82.0

94.2

33.7

36.7

Manning

77.9

83.8

31.7

34.1

Bighorn Mtn. foothills

1993

7.0

Redwin

71.1

78.8

32.4

33.8

Manning

53.7

60.3

28.6

30.3

CDC Kestrel

64.5

70.5

30.5

31.3

Bighorn Mtn. foothills

1994

4.3

Redwin

50.9

55.3

30.9

33.4

Manning

64.3

70.6

32.9

33.7

CDC Kestrel

58.1

61.5

29.7

31.2

Bighorn Mtn. foothills

1995

3.3

Redwin

71.2

80.1

31.9

34.7

Sierra

87.9

94.5

33.5

36.7

Manning

87.9

98.2

31.0

33.9

CDC Kestrel

76.9

90.7

28.4

32.0

Fort Smith

1995

3.0

Redwin

77.1

86.2

33.7

35.6

Sierra

86.1

89.7

34.8

36.9

Manning

90.2

95.5

32.4

34.4

CDC Kestrel

76.3

88.4

29.5

31.8

Average

70.0

76.9

31.8

34.1


-Cl = control, no chloride fertilizer applied       
§ +Cl = chloride fertilized applied at a rate of 40 lbs/a and 60 lbs/a for 1991-1992 and 1993-1995 studies, respectively.